In the policies we place, a medium-sized epoxy business carrying general liability, workers’ comp, commercial auto and an umbrella pays $2,500 to $10,000 or more a year for the whole program. The umbrella’s share depends on the limit, the policies beneath it and the floors you coat.
An umbrella is not priced on its own. It is priced on the layer it sits over, so the cost question is really two questions: what the umbrella costs, and what the policies underneath must look like before a carrier will write it. This post takes both, along with the contracts that make an umbrella necessary.
Is an umbrella worth it for a small epoxy crew?
For a one- or two-person crew coating garages for homeowners, an umbrella is a judgment call rather than a requirement. Nobody is asking for it, and the general liability and auto policies may be enough for the work. The case for one grows as the business takes on more exposure: a second truck and trailer, a crew working in occupied commercial buildings, floors in places where crowds walk every day.
The question to ask is not whether an umbrella is cheap but what a single large claim would do to the business without one. If a serious road accident or a slip on a busy commercial floor could exceed your primary limits, the umbrella is what stands between that claim and the company’s own assets. If your work and your contracts never come near those limits, the money may be better spent elsewhere in the program for now.
What does an umbrella cost an epoxy flooring contractor?
The umbrella is one part of a program price. A crew that coats residential garages and carries no contract requirements may not need one at all. A business with commercial customers, several vehicles and a written limit requirement in its contracts will, and it is that business the range above describes.
The umbrella layer is priced from the point where the primary policies stop. A carrier looks at your general liability, your auto liability and your employer’s liability, at what you do and at your claims, and then sets a price for the limit you ask for. A larger limit costs more, but the next layer of limit is not priced the same as the first, which is why a quote for two different limits rarely scales in a straight line.
The California Department of Insurance commercial insurance guide describes a commercial umbrella as liability coverage above the limits of the underlying policies, and the NAIC glossary of insurance terms defines excess and umbrella liability in the same terms.
What an umbrella sits over
An umbrella for an epoxy contractor rests on three liability policies. General liability answers claims from the work: a slip on a fresh floor, damage to a customer’s property, a coating that fails after the job and harms something else. Commercial auto answers claims from the trucks and trailers that carry the crew and the grinders. The employer’s liability part of workers’ compensation answers suits tied to a worker’s injury that fall outside the comp benefits themselves.
When a covered claim uses up the limit of one of those policies, the umbrella can pay above it, up to its own limit and subject to its own terms. Our umbrella liability coverage page explains how the layer works on a coating job. This post stays with the price.
When an epoxy business adds an umbrella
The trigger is a contract. In the policies we place, the umbrella arrives when a general contractor, property manager or public owner sets liability limits above what a primary policy carries. A garage-floor business working for homeowners rarely meets that demand. A business bidding warehouses, schools, food plants or retail floors meets it on job after job, and an umbrella tends to join the program in the season a crew wins its first large commercial customer.
Contracts are not the only reason. A business running several trucks and trailers has more auto exposure, and a serious road accident can exceed an auto policy’s limit. A business coating large commercial floors has more people walking on its work. Our commercial epoxy flooring contractor insurance page shows how that work changes the program as a whole.
Real-World Scenario: An epoxy contractor bids a floor in a food-processing plant. The plant’s contract asks for liability limits above what the contractor’s general liability policy carries, and it wants the plant covered as an additional insured on every layer. The agent quotes an umbrella and learns that the umbrella carrier expects higher auto limits underneath than the contractor carries. The auto limits are raised, the umbrella is bound, and the agent confirms that the umbrella extends to the plant as the contract requires. The contractor builds the combined cost of the umbrella and the higher auto limits into the bid before signing.
What moves the umbrella’s price
A short list of factors carries the weight in an umbrella quote for a coating business.
The first is the limit. A higher limit costs more, though each added layer is priced on how likely a claim is to reach it.
The second is the work. Garage floors and occasional small commercial jobs are a narrower risk than food plants, warehouses and public buildings, where more people walk on the finished floor and a failure affects more property.
The third is vehicles. An umbrella sits over auto liability, so more trucks, trailers and drivers raise its price as well as the auto policy’s.
The fourth is history. Past liability claims, especially large ones, tell the umbrella carrier how often claims reach the primary limits.
Why the policies underneath have to line up
Every umbrella carrier sets minimum limits it expects on the policies beneath it. If your auto or general liability limits sit below those minimums, they have to be raised before the umbrella is written, and that change has its own price. A quote that shows only the umbrella layer can understate what the step costs.
The underlying policies also have to stay in force. If a primary policy lapses or its limit is used up by earlier claims, the umbrella does not simply drop down to fill the whole gap unless its terms say so. Ask for the umbrella and the underlying policies to be quoted, renewed and reviewed together, ideally with the same agent, so the layers stay aligned. The NAIC small business insurance page lists umbrella business liability among the coverages a growing business may add.
What an umbrella does not do
An umbrella extends limits. It does not turn an excluded loss into a covered one. The cost of grinding off and redoing your own failed floor stays outside the liability policies, and the umbrella follows them. The Texas Department of Insurance guide to commercial general liability explains the exclusions a general liability policy carries, and an umbrella written over that policy is read alongside them.
Pollution is another place to look carefully. Coating vapors and solvents can raise questions under pollution exclusions in both the primary policy and the umbrella. Our post on contractors pollution liability covers that question, and our post on completed operations coverage explains which failed-floor claims the liability layer can answer.
Reading the limit requirement in a contract
Before you buy an umbrella for a contract, read what the contract actually asks for. Some contracts let the required limits be met with any mix of primary and umbrella coverage. Some ask for the customer to be covered as an additional insured on the umbrella as well as the general liability. Some ask for a waiver of subrogation on every layer.
Send the insurance section to your agent before you sign. The certificate your agent issues will need to show the umbrella in the way the contract asks, and our post on the certificate of insurance for contractors explains what that document proves and what it does not. The Texas Department of Insurance certificates FAQ answers common questions about how certificates are issued.
What to send for an umbrella quote
Bring the umbrella carrier what it prices from:
- the limit your contracts require, with the insurance sections attached
- your current general liability, auto and employer’s liability limits
- the vehicles and drivers on the auto policy
- the mix of garage, commercial and industrial floors you coat
- your loss runs for the liability policies
If you are still sizing the policies underneath, our post on the cost of general liability for an epoxy business is the place to start. When you have the contract in hand, request a quote and we will price the umbrella and the layer beneath it together.